Saturday, April 28, 2007
For once, the U.S. and EU governments were in absolute synch and reached a reasonable conclusion. They warned Turkey's military on April 28 that, no matter what happened in Abdullah Gul's race for president, the military staff needed to respect democracy and not intervene, as they have far too many times in the last 50 years. The only observation to make to the military's credit is that the officers seemed much less worried about Gul's candidacy than about the new effort by some Islamic radicals in Turkey to intimidate secularists and enforce the sharia. In that they have a right to be concerned.
Turkey's military is faced with the problem that Algeria faced in 1992. What if an Islamic electoral party is leading in an election, yet freely admits it is not interested in upholding democracy after coming to power? The Algerian government canceled elections and faced a decade of a brutal terror war. Turkey does not really face such a problem, since Gul and Prime Minister Erdogan are among the nation's biggest modernizers.
For a military dedicated to secularism, the problem of "creeping Islam" can't be minimized. If a government is to respect human rights and equality of opportunity, it simply must be secular-based. Faith-based social policy and decisions made on the basis of sharia (or Scripture, for that matter) constitute de facto violations of human rights.
But the solution Kemal Ataturk came up with is no solution. In the coups of 1960 and 1980, the Turkish army instituted a brand of fascism that was far worse than the radicalism or creeping Islam it sought to replace. In the past, Jimmy Carter winked at the 1980 coup to preserve access to intelligence bases in Turkey, so the Bush administration's warning should be seen as a tiny step forward.
Since the EU still is debating Turkey's entry to that body, the position of its members is worth examining. Basically, European nations (many of whom are arguing their own limits to sharia) are suggesting that Islam in government can be limited, but only by civilian authorities. The problem with halting Islam through use of the army is a basic issue of the armed forces' place in society, and a resolution requires a modification of Turkey's constitution. Since that is highly unlikely, Turkey's entry into the EU is equally unlikely.
The role of Turkey's army has significance far beyond the Gul candidacy. Since the army is committed to upholding the (near-sacred) memory of Ataturk, it prodded the government to institute a ban on YouTube after some crude anti-Ataturk videos appeared. Defenders of true democracy recognize that there are no heroes above reproach, even heroes of the revolution. George Washington and Thomas Jefferson are regularly excoriated in this country for slave-owning and shady dealings. A democracy that lionizes its founders and prevents critiques of them is no democracy.
Whatever happens to Turkey in the next few months cannot be good - a military coup, a near-civil war, or growing Islamic terror against secularists seem to be the choices. But in any event, the military belongs back in its barracks unless and until the political situation deteriorates into gunfire in the streets. In the meantime, we can kiss goodbye to Turkey in the EU.
May 1 Addendum
At least the Constitutional Courts acted instead of the military, and maybe all the protesting pro-secularists are happy, but this is all beginning to smell very much like Algeria. Not a good thing.
Friday, April 20, 2007
Monday, April 16, 2007
When I was a teenager, the popularity of the Weebles toys insured that every time I got drunk, I heard several rounds of "Wirbels wobble but they don't fall down." Now, Wilco is moving in the same wobbly direction. Pictured are the complete set of Wilco toys, as discussed in a recent Pitchfork article.
Friday, April 13, 2007
Vonnegut is Dead; David Rovics is Alive; Phyllis Bennis is Kickin' Ass; Protesters Are on Trial; Space Symposium Warriors are ASAT-Scrappin'
Sorry for the extended silence. April 9 was an exhausting week, working two gigs at once and trying to keep up with events around town, while not collapsing. This is the week Kurt Vonnegut died, a milestone I expected. He considered the success of his last book to be a glass of champagne at the end of life, so no tears are required.
In this week:
* Phyllis Bennis (left) came to town and warned us not to exaggerate the difference between the "prudent imperialists" of the Clinton era and the present gang of "reckless empire-drivers." She offered lots of strategies to end the Iraq war and made short work of the Colin Powell "Pottery Barn" excuse for staying in Iraq: "When a bull is in the china shop, you don't negotiate with the bull to clean up after himself. You get the bull out of the china shop as quickly as possible."
* David Rovics (right) played the Gill Foundation on the eve of his 40th birthday, offering several songs very appropriate to Colorado Springs. Barb Doyle and Annie Garretson opened for him. Great show, and David Rovics is a great guy.
* The protesters who were dragged out of the St. Patrick's Day parade got their day in court Tuesday, and Bill Sulzman made the front page of the Colorado Springs Gazette waving a peace flag.
* The space warriors were out in force at the National Space Symposium, and debated arcane issues of space security. Surprisingly, both the head of Strategic Command and the director of the National Reconnaissance Office said that the Air Force Chief of Staff had been too alarmist regarding the Jan. 11 China ASAT test.
Sunday, April 1, 2007
Article in today's Jerusalem Post quotes Russian intelligence officials who claim the U.S. has a missile strike ready to launch against Iranian targets on Good Friday. Something tells me this isn't an April Fool's joke, though Russia may be using cooked intelligence from the U.S. to add to the hype and increase pressure to release the British hostages. Then again, since the Bush administration is too blunt for the double- or triple-cross, they may just be planning to bomb the bejesus out of Iran on Good Friday.